New York Court of Appeals

William M. Condon, Appellant v. Associated Hospital Service of New York, Respondents

March 5, 1942287 N.Y. 411

Summary

The Court held that the plaintiff's complaint sufficiently alleged a breach of an express contract with the individual defendants, reversing the dismissal of that cause of action, while affirming dismissal of the claim against the corporate defendant as a pure copyright infringement action outside state jurisdiction. The decision rests on liberal construction of pleadings to preserve a contract claim and the principle that copyright infringement is exclusively federal.