New York Court of Appeals

Joseph Gillet, as Assignee for the Benefit of Creditors of John F. Talmage and Daniel Talmage

November 21, 1899160 N.Y. 549

Summary

The Court of Appeals held that the bank’s collateral provision in a printed note prepared by the bank was limited to liabilities of the customer to the bank arising from their banking relationship and did not extend to a third‑party claim the bank purchased. Accordingly, the bank’s retention of the pledged securities to secure the $5,000 note was an unauthorized breach of trust and conversion, so the trial court’s verdict for the plaintiff was affirmed and the Appellate Division’s reversal was reversed.