New York Court of Appeals

The People, Ex Rel. William McDonald v. . William H. Keeler, as Sheriff

October 6, 188599 N.Y. 463

Summary

The Court of Appeals held that New York's statutory power to punish contempt for refusing to attend or be examined as a witness before a legislative committee is constitutional, that the Senate's investigation was a legitimate legislative proceeding, that witnesses before such committees have no constitutional right to counsel, and that the Penal Code does not repeal the statutory contempt provisions; it reversed the General Term's discharge and affirmed the lower court's imprisonment, remanding the relator to the sheriff's custody.